top of page
Search

The Death of the Dinosaurs and the Start of a New American Life?

Writer: sara john
sara john
Nov 7
5 min read

By Samir al-Taqi

After the American elections of November 3, Ron DeSantis, the Republican governor of Florida, described the results as “not merely a tsunami, but something more like the meteor that struck the Earth and wiped out the dinosaurs.” It was a splendid way of capturing the depth of the transformation whose first tremors these elections marked. And we are still only at the beginning of that transformation.

In December 1799, George Washington fell gravely ill, and his physicians bled him until he had lost more than a third of his blood. And so the founder of the republic died not of the disease, but of the cure first and foremost. This is precisely what Trump did to America. He rose in a moment of political and institutional vacuum, to confront a deep crisis in the country.

Trump understood the disease better than his rivals, and he proposed smashing the party bureaucracy in Washington. But he overdid the treatment of the American crisis: he went too far in dismantling the elites and the bureaucracy. Instead of renewing them, he shattered them with nothing to put in their place, so that corporate influence deepened and ethical restraints loosened. This hemorrhage of the bureaucratic elite, and his failure to replace it, bled away Trump's own chances, exactly as the excessive bloodletting drained the life from America's Founding Father.

The punishment was severe. Kansas had not sent a Democrat to the Senate in nearly a century, and then it did. So too did Iowa, Ohio, Maine, North and South Carolina, and even Texas. And while the president had asked voters to imagine him on the ballot, they answered his request with an enthusiasm he himself had not wished for.

More important than the punishment is what followed it. After Trump said he was “fully prepared” to work with the Democrats, the markets celebrated, for no reason other than that he would depart in peace.

Such is the genius of the American experiment, and its curse. Roughly every four decades, crises shake its foundations to the edge of collapse, and from one era to the next, America reproduces itself. Every age has its state and its men. The most important thing is that it reproduces its elites. America liquidates the dinosaurs without mercy and unleashes new species of elites. Carlota Perez described it thus: “Every technological revolution begins with a speculative bubble in the markets, which soon collapses, then produces new institutions that govern a new age.”

This has happened in America again and again. In 1929, the agrarian republic clashed with the growth of large-scale industrial production, so the generation of Roosevelt replaced the generation of Hoover, and the social contract changed in the “New Deal.” In the mid-1960s came the generation of the hippies and the protests, to restructure post-industrial America. Then in 2008, high technology, digital platforms, and accelerating globalization hollowed out America's industrial heartland, wealth piled up on its coasts, and the elites of both parties grew flabby and decayed.

At that point Trump represented an enormous opportunity for a transfusion of new blood into the Republican Party, and into the republic. He was expected to overturn the table in the face of the bureaucracy and the rotten elites of both parties. But he soon failed to produce alternative elites, and, more importantly, he failed to draw a modern strategy for an America after artificial intelligence and the biological revolution, and the rest.

The Democrats learned the lesson of 2024. Their elder, Obama, led the process of changing the party's blood and liquidating its dinosaurs: from Clinton and Pelosi through to Harris and Newsom. In this wave, the Democrats pushed new generations of the young, of women, and of minorities to the front of political life. Women make up 42 percent of the party's representatives, against 15 percent among their rivals, while the Republicans deepened their ideological isolation. And so the transfusion of elite blood was not the fruit of victory, but a cause of it.

This picture looks beautiful, but it is dangerous at the same time. For the Democrats must acknowledge that their win was a punishment of Trump more than it was a victory for an advanced program carried by the new Democratic elites. A party that won by virtue of the public mood is now obliged to produce an economic and political program for an America in a climate where automation and artificial intelligence devour the opportunities of the traditional workforce.

Many Democrats already complain that they are in a state of sweeping political chaos, which recalls Will Rogers's line: “I am not a member of any organized party. I am a Democrat.” For it is not enough that the Democrats acknowledge the diversity of identities; they must produce an integrated social program serving the forces of production, of business, and of the modern workforce.

For its part, after its plain defeat, the Republican Party suffers a glaring structural vacuum. It too needs a transfusion of new blood and a fresh conception of the right, of the role of capital, and of the role of the state in the age of artificial intelligence.

The vote on November 3 was a circumstantial phenomenon, governed by prices and by war. But this American crisis is not a passing one; it is a deep, organic crisis: an economy being rebuilt by artificial intelligence and by modern, unleashed capital, while the modern state possesses nothing but an antiquated, impotent political system designed for the industrial age.

Moreover, the new has not yet been born. The Democratic alternative is still an embryo, and the Republican alternative has yet to bear fruit of its own, while the crisis of 2008 deepens across society as a whole. Churchill is credited with the saying that Americans always do the right thing, but only after they have exhausted every wrong alternative. And America is still exhausting them. That, as we have said, is the genius of American chaos, and its curse.

By contrast, we cannot yet say that the direction of American foreign policy has settled or clearly shifted, but what will certainly change is its instruments. Moscow and Beijing read the result as confirmation of what they already believe: that the shelf life of Washington's promises does not outlast the next election. China will bet on time, and Russia will bet on the gap between a White House that cuts deals and a Congress that hardens against it and seeks to strike it.

Trump is accustomed to acting alone, using executive orders, but he will now be forced to yield to a Congress that holds the purse and the power to investigate and audit. When the new Congress is sworn in, we will see a defeated president who nonetheless does not fear a new election, and who indeed holds the decision of war with Iran in his hand. The deal may seem to Trump the wiser choice, but the decisive strike may be the more tempting one.

Most likely, history will record November 2026 as the beginning of the founding of America's third era. And unless the Democrats can cement their success by producing an economic and political program, the Republicans of the post-Trump era will be lying in wait for them. They too are drawing their own lessons and sharpening their tools, and they may well become more ready than the Democrats suppose. This is why DeSantis, the Republican governor of Florida, looks like a danger that frightens Trump and MAGA as much as it frightens the Democratic leaders. Article link https://www.annahar.com/articles/annahar-writers/364160/%D9%85%D9%88%D8%AA-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%AF%D9%8A%D9%86%D8%A7%D8%B5%D9%88%D8%B1%D8%A7%D8%AA-%D9%88%D8%A8%D8%AF%D8%A7%D9%8A%D8%A9-%D8%AD%D9%8A%D8%A7%D8%A9-%D8%A3%D9%85%D9%8A%D8%B1%D9%83%D9%8A%D8%A9-%D8%AC%D8%AF%D9%8A%D8%AF%D8%A9

 
 
 

Comments


© 2020 by Insight Advisory Group

  • LinkedIn Social Icon
  • Twitter Social Icon
bottom of page